Reviewer Guidelines
Presentation
- Does the paper relate a cohesive argument? Are the ideas clearly presented?
Writing
- Does the title characterize the manuscript? Is the writing concise and easy to follow?
Length
- What portions of the paper should be expanded? Removed? Condensed? Summarized?
Combined?
Combined?
Title
- Is the title concise, omitting terms that are implicit and, where possible, a statement of the main result or conclusion presented in the manuscript? Abbreviations should be avoided within the title.
Abstract
- Does the abstract consist of 1) the aim of the study, 2) the method, 3) the result or finding, and 4) the conclusion?
Introduction
- Clearly describe and respectively:
- The background of the study;
- State-of-the-art, relevant research to justify the novelty of the manuscript;
- Gap analysis, novelty statement;
- Hypothesis or problem statement (optional);
- Approach to resolve the problem; and
- The aim of the study.
Method
- The method is written clearly so that other researchers can replicate the experiment or research with the same result;
- Describe not only the definition of terms but also how to conduct the research;
- Describe the location, participants, research instrument, and data analysis;
Result and discussion
- The data presented has been processed (not raw data) into a table or figure and given a supportive description which easy to follow.
- The result related to the original questions or objectives outlined in the Introduction section.
- The author describes the result of the study consistent with what other investigators have reported, or if there are any differences.
- The author provides an interpretation for each of the results or findings presented.
- The author describes the implications of the research.
- The author describes the limitations of the research or drawbacks to the method or position.
- The author describes further need/areas for research or expansion of ideas.
Conclusion
Consist of:
- Answer the objectives of the research;
- Implication or recommendation (optional);
- Written in a paragraph, not in bullet/numbering.